“Put your hand on a hot stove for a minute, and it seems like an hour. Sit with a pretty girl for an hour, and it seems like a minute. That’s relativity.”
Albert Einstein

Week 9 Quick Hits

Monday, October 30th 2006
Uncategorized



Some People Get Happy - Just Not Me

  • Three loses in almost four seasons…
  • …two national championships…
  • …four BCS Bowls…
  • …three Heisman trophies…
  • …that is what Pete Carroll has brough to Southern California
  • JDB is going to have to stop throwing tipped passes (an odd complaint to start out with I know…but…com’n man, just get the ball up)
  • Steve Smith continues to be the brightest spot on this team
  • Can Rey please show up for team meetings on time?
  • Not that he always knows what he’s doing on the field…
  • …maybe Oscar is the better option as we search for some leadership
  • Dagnabit, Brent Schaefer can’t you pull off the upset?!
  • Auburn, Michigan, Louisville, Florida, Texas, and West Virginia all look vulnerable
  • This is going to be chaos in the BCS
  • It looks like DJ is sleepwalking through the game
  • It is hard to be impressed with the heart needed for that comeback considering we lost, but I appreciated the effort
  • For weeks I called for us to blitz more…
  • …because the 3-4 isn’t working and LoJack and Ellis seem lost and playing without passion…
  • …now we do and we see the holes it opens up in our weak, young secondary
  • We have to go to a 4-3
  • We have to hold onto the ball
  • We have to take more shots down field
  • There’s always a chance in a big rivalry game…
  • …but even though they’re both undefeated, with the way they’ve been playing don’t you have to make Ohio State like 2 touchdown favorites on November 8th
  • Is this defense reallly any better than 2004?
  • For all the hype maybe some of these hard hitting linebackers have reached the max of their Football IQ
  • Maybe for all their stars we can’t expect any more out of these players…
  • Chilo? Moala? Cushing? Maualuga?
  • …high school reps aren’t college reps…
  • …and especially the guys on defense, besides making big hits have some of these linebackers shown much else?
  • I thought Pete’s key to the offseason was fixing special teams…
  • …apparently not
  • That was a godawfully easy return for a TD
  • Is Rutgers for real?
  • Because giving a lead to Conneticut doesn’t inspire confidence
  • Can an undefeated Big East team hold off a Florida or Auburn?
  • Wow, Nebraska really isn’t that good…
  • …but maybe the Cowboys will give the Longhorns something to chew on next weekend
  • Tough loss for impressive QB Bell, at Baylor
  • With supreme optimism I have some predictions for the remainder of the season. If I’m right I’ll look like a genius. If I’m wrong, no one will remember.
  • How The Season Will Play Out:
  • USC runs the table and goes 11-1…
  • …including a trouncing of Cal
  • On November 2 Louisville beats West Virginia
  • On November 4 Tennessee loses to LSU
  • On November 18th ‘Bama upsets Auburn, Ohio State crushes Michigan
  • On November 24th Texas struggles with Texas A&M
  • On November 25th Louisville loses to Pitt, Florida struggles against Florida State
  • on December 2 Arkansas beats Florida in the SEC Championship, Texas struggles with Missouri in the Big 12 Championship, Boston College wins the ACC
  • Rutgers finishes the season with one loss and wins the Big East
  • Boise State goes undefeated and qualifies for a BCS bid
  • Cal finishes 10-2, Notre Dame finishes 10-2, Arkansas finishes 11-2 (other loss being to LSU)
  • USC finishes #2 in 5 of the 6 BCS computers, #3 in one BCS human poll and #4 in the other
  • On December 3 USC leapfrogs Texas by the slimest of margains into the #2 spot for the final BCS rankings creating outrage
  • The Rose Bowl passes on several two loss SEC teams to take a two loss BCS eligible Cal
  • The Sugar Bowl does the same, jumping at a chance to take Notre Dame (who despite not being high enough for an automatic bid are still BCS eligible as an at-large)
  • There’s outrage and pandemonium througout the southeast as “the country’s toughest conference” gets only one BCS bid
  • National Championship: Ohio State v. USC
  • Rose Bowl: Cal v. Michigan
  • Sugar Bowl: Arkansas v. Notre Dame
  • Orange Bowl: Rutgers v. Boston College
  • Fiesta Bowl: Texas v. Boise State

Week 9 Poll Challenge


Uncategorized

Ranking To Date Rating System Score
1 Sagarin (Predictor) 65*
2 Sagarin 67 (128)
T-3 Wolfe 69 (104)
T-3 Colley Matrix 69 (107)
5 Massey 78
6 Anderson 115
7 Harris 116
8 AP 118
9 Coaches’ 120
10 BCS 122
11 Billingsley 144

Sagarin, Wolfe, Massey, and Colley Matrix benefited mightily as none of those ranking systems had Nebraska in the Top 25. This was especially true for Sagarin’s Elo-Chess which had a 61 point differential between Oklahoma State and Nebraska. Seeing as this was supposed to be a measurement using Top 25 upsets, they didn’t suffer from Oklahoma State’s win and now are clearly running away with the competition.

The numbers in parathensis are their point totals if the Oklahoma State upset counted against them. There are however too many non-top 25 upsets to calculate the points, and so if a rating system doesn’t think enough of a team to rank them in the top 25 it will continue to not count against them.

It should be noted that that doesn’t apply to Sagarin’s predictor model, who although I “theorized” what it might’ve scored last week (remember I didn’t have the numbers for it last week) is still clearly the most accurate ratings system so far. Even though it had Nebraska in its top 25, it trounced the competition especially in terms of its estimation of Virginia Tech (who upset Clemson).

The human polls were devestated, more by their overestimation of Nebraska than the USC loss actually. Billingsley shot himself in the foot with an abysmal ranking of Oregon State and especially of Oklahoma State. It’s going to take something special to recover.

Sportswriters Write Without Understanding

Sunday, October 29th 2006
Uncategorized

Titles like “USC Plummets In Polls,” don’t really capture the true spirit of the situation.

The BCS rankings aren’t out, and neither is the Harris poll but USC is #9 in both the AP and Coaches’. We’ll be #9 or 10 in the Harris. As such here are Tellshow’s estimations for the BCS rankings this week, before they come out:

1 Ohio State
2 Michigan
3 West Virginia
4 Florida
5 Auburn
6 Louisville
7 Texas
8 Southern Cal
9 California
10 Notre Dame
11 Tennessee

Significant damage. USC no longer controls its own destiny. Not that it looks like USC could’ve made use of that control with upcoming games against Cal, ND, and Oregon.

BUT it is much less severe than people imagine. In fact, this is just about the best USC could’ve hoped for. If Tellshow is right we will hold off Tennessee if we win out (even though the Volunteers are about to get a boost in their strength of schedule with some upcoming tough games).

2 of the top 6 teams have to lose. We’re hoping that whoever wins the Michigan - Ohio State game does it soundly, so as to attenuate the losers fall in the human polls. The “good” news is that the loser plays no other games to “make up” for the loss.

But we should easily jump the loser of the West Virginia - Louisville game.

As I predicted we need Auburn, Florida and the winner of the Louisville - West Virginia game to lose.

Those are five BIG IFs: Ohio State - Michigan winner wins big, West Virginia - Louisville winner loses, Florida loses, Auburn loses, USC wins out

But if those came to pass I think we possibly could jump Texas and hold off Tennessee and the Michigan - Ohio State loser for the #2 spot. Texas’ computer ranking will improve significantly, but USC’s will as well. If the scenario above played out I don’t think Texas could close to within more than .08 or so of USC in the computer % (especially with the way the Big 12 North is playing right now).

In the chaos that would entail us getting to this scenario there’s almost no chance Texas could expect to hold the huge lead as the #2 team that Michigan currently does over #3 West Virginia (~.05 in both polls).

It isn’t even close to a certainty under such fluid circumstances, but it is a real possibility that would be enough to jump Texas and hold off Tennessee. The margin in the computers between USC and the Michigan - Ohio State loser would be less but hopefully they’ll have fallen a bit in the polls.

I think I’ll go hum the Monkees, seeing as I’m just day dreaming here.

The more realistic question is if an undefeated Big East team can hold off a Florida team that wins out.

Florida’s strength of schedule over the remainder of its season is pretty bad (Vandy, South Carolina, West Carolina, Florida State). The Gators will get a boost from the SEC championship game. As well, they might move up in the computers after November 18th and if USC (or someone else) beats Cal.

Either Big East team can probably hold off Florida. Still it’ll be a contentious argument over that #2 spot.

*UPDATE*

Tellshow was nearly on the money. Flip Auburn and Louisville in the official standings:

1 Ohio State
2 Michigan
3 West Virginia
4 Florida
5 Louisville
6 Auburn
7 Texas
8 Southern Cal
9 California
10 Notre Dame
11 Tennessee

Craptacular Doesn’t Begin To Describe It


Uncategorized

I went .500 last week in my picks. I felt more confident this week and so far I’ve managed an 8 - 9 record. My four “confident” games? I went 2 - 2. We’re talking an implosion the last two weeks on par with The U.


Happier Times

And of course, the Trojans lost (after deciding to stress all of us by making a huge comeback effort).

USC is a historical program, with a swagger. It benefits (and suffers) from that image. Before the Rose Bowl last year we had Kirk Herbstriet calling the Trojans the greatest team ever. Now, looking back the pundits quickly realized how foolish they had sounded. There reaction was to immediately start disparaging this Trojan team. They sat on the edge of their seats “knowing” the Trojans were going to screw up. Nevermind these are the same dumbwits who picked teams like Miami and Notre Dame to play for the national championship.

That won’t matter when the human polls are released. All that pent up hate is going to cause the Trojans to plumnet, disproportionately to being a one loss team.

And the rest of the college football world can smile. But, they’re all morons.


Your Average College Football Fan & Sports Writer

I say that NOT because they’re glad to see USC’s demise. But because they think they’ve witnessed USC’s demise. The subtleties of the BCS are lost on these people. It isn’t a terribly complicated system. And a little understanding of it would show that the Trojan haters should at least wait for another loss.

Why do I say that? Because the computers love USC. And the love is only going to grow if the Trojans win out, because the computer love is based on strength of schedule and the toughest part of the Trojan’s season hasn’t even begun.

At the time of writing only Sagarin’s computer rankings are out but the Trojans are fifth. I wouldn’t expect them to fall farther than eight in any computer rankings (there are six used for the BCS rankings). Ahead of Tennessee, ahead of Louisville, ahead of West Virginia, ahead of Texas in basically every computer.

It is my opinion that there are only three teams “effectively” ahead of USC in the BCS for the #2 spot.

USC is going to get trounced in the human polls, no doubt about that. Hopefully the fall won’t be lower than 11th or 12th. That hurts. But if, and that is a big if, the Trojans win out their strength of schedule may boost them all the way up to the second spot in the computer average. Now they’ll still need a lot of help in terms of other teams losing in the human polls. But there are several teams, who might be in front of USC in the next BCS, who we can ignore because they’ll be effectively jumped.

Let’s have a look at the teams that “might” be in front of USC in the next BCS this afternoon:

  • Ohio State
  • Michigan (Either Ohio State Or Michigan Has To Lose)
  • West Virginia (Either West Virginia Or Louisville Has To Lose)
  • Auburn
  • Florida
  • Texas (Weak Computer Ranking Means Might Be Able To Be Jumped)
  • Louisville
  • Notre Dame (USC Plays, Controls Own Destiny)
  • Cal (USC Plays, Controls Own Destiny)
  • Tennessee (Weak Computer Ranking Means Might Be Able To Be Jumped)

So, if the Trojans win out (if I win the lottery), there is a liklihood that there are only three teams we need to lose a game to make it to the MNC. Auburn, Florida and the winner of Louisville-West Virginia game. Not unreasonable especially for Auburn and the Louisville - West Virginia winner. Auburn has looked weak and defeatable the last few weeks against mediocore opponents (kind’ve like USC before their loss to Oregon State). Louisville and West Virginia both have to play Pitt and Rutgers still.

Florida is a tougher cookie but can we say Arkansas in the SEC championship game?

If we can win out and work our way back to within a spot of say, Texas, in the human polls…there’s no doubt with our computer strength we’ll jump a team like that in the BCS.

Of course, it seems unlikely right now that USC can run the rest of its schedule especially facing Cal, Notre Dame, and Oregon. As well USC may plumnet even lower than predicted in the human polls, making this trip more difficult. So all this day dreaming is probably moot.

But all those haters should note, it is not implausible that USC (despite being ranked lower than these teams in this week’s BCS) will actually be in a better position than one loss teams like Tennessee and Texas and even maybe an undefeated team like Louisville.

Missed Deadlines

Saturday, October 28th 2006
UncategorizedMiscellaneousLaw

Liestoppers has a write up providing evidence that Nifong has missed a discovery deadline. If you’re interested in the Duke case Liestoppers is a great website.

They also have a link to an effort to recall DA Mike Nifong.

Tragedy Of The Commons & Medicine


Healthcare PolicyPoliticsUninsuredHealthcare CostsSingle Payer

Medrants has a great post on the idea of ‘Tragedy of the Commons’ and how it relates to health care costs and disparities.

The idea is how the very libertarian principle of “everyman for himself” is harmful when it comes to the overexploitation of public finite resources. For example, overgrazing a “common.”

Here is Wikipedia’s article on the thoery. You should however read DB’s post.

I Need Not Know What Happened…

Friday, October 27th 2006
UncategorizedMiscellaneousLaw


“Conversations”? No. Telepathic Communication Though…He Didn’t Deny That

If you needed MORE evidence the Duke lacrosse rape case was a joke, District Attorney Mike Nifong admitted today, he has not actually talked to the accuser about the case,

“One of the most interesting things to me of course is Mr. Nifong did admit that he in fact has basically never talked to this woman and has absolutely no idea what her story is, and yet he has chosen to continue to go forward with this case,” defense lawyer Joseph Cheshire said.

Nifong said none of his assistants have discussed the case with the woman either and only have spoken with her to monitor her well-being. They have left the investigation of the case to police, he said.

H/T Drudge

Page 10N: Iran Steps Up Uranium Enrichment


PoliticsMiscellaneousInternationalIranian Nukes

When Drudge isn’t posting about Virginia Senatorial candidate Webb writing about a man sticking a boy’s privates in his mouth (which as The Irish Trojan has noted is a stupid point for the media to rally around), he’s linking to stories about Iran’s continued press forward with enrichment,

Iran has doubled its capacity to enrich uranium by successfully executing the process with a second network of centrifuges, a semiofficial news agency reported Friday, sending a defiant new message to the U.N. Security Council.

Council members are working on a draft resolution that would impose limited sanctions on the Islamic republic because of its refusal to cease enrichment, a process that can produce fuel for a civilian nuclear reactor or fissile material for a warhead.

Luckily our beret wearing allies have some strong words,

France’s Foreign Ministry called Iran’s expansion of its nuclear program a “negative signal” that should be taken to account at U.N. talks over possible sanctions.

A spokesman for the ministry, Jean-Baptiste Mattei, said the Iranian announcement was not a great surprise because the IAEA, the U.N. nuclear watchdog, had said in August that Iran was developing new nuclear capacities.

“The door to negotiations is always open, but at the same time the priority goes to the negotiations for a U.N. Security Council resolution,” Mattei said at a news conference.

French President Jacques Chirac, meanwhile, expressed support for sanctions against Iran but insisted that they be temporary and reversible.

Better than the Russians at present though,

Russian Defense Minister Sergei Ivanov said he didn’t “share concerns” about the launching of a second network of centrifuges, expressing confidence that the new centrifuges “are under the complete control of the International Atomic Energy Agency, for scientific research purposes.”

He also said the centrifuges were “completely empty, so to talk about enriched uranium or uranium for military use, is at the very least premature.”

The basis of his statement was unclear, however. The IAEA monitors both “cascades” of centrifuges, but they are not under its “complete control,” as Ivanov asserted. And - unlike Ivanov - the Iranian official cited by ISNA said the second network was no longer empty but enriching small amounts of uranium.

Other Russian officials also had shared previously shared the opinion of the United States and its western allies, Britain, France and Germany that even “dry testing” centrifuges was cause for concern.

Preview: Oregon State


Uncategorized

Short and sweet. Short and sweet. Such I will have to keep this as I prepare for school related events.

The Trojans are coming off a bye week, in which their previous competition (Nebraska, Washington, Washington State) for which they were questioned for “struggling” against (nevermind the Trojans have trailed 5 minutes ALL season), all performed well and proved their metle.

The Beavers are 4 - 3, including a win over Washington. They’re on a 2 game role.


Plus Their Mascot Is Fearsome

Oregon St. Offense v. USC Defense

Offense isn’t the Beaver’s strong suit. They did lose last year’s Biletnikof winner…a stunner for an Oregon State player to grab an award that prestigous (just kidding).

The Beavers have struggled all season to sustain drives and score touchdowns.

And even though QB Moore has had some success against the Trojans in trash time in the past (as a UCLA player), he has not played particularly well this year.

[I]t has been four years since Moore and the Trojans were on the same football field.

In 2002, when Moore was a true freshman at UCLA, the now-OSU senior appeared as a reserve at quarterback, completing 7-of-11 passes for 64 yards and a touchdown at the Rose Bowl in Pasadena, Calif.

Moore’s efforts did little to help, however. The Trojans rolled past the Bruins 55-21 en route to an 11-2 season that was capped by a victory over Iowa at the Orange Bowl.

Moore has been inconsistent at times. For instance he’s at 6 touchdowns and 6 interceptions but in his last two games - against Arizona and Washington - the kid has completed over 72% of his passes.

With only one game over 200 yards it speaks to the Beavers reliance on the running game. And the Beavers are lucky it looks like there is a slim possibility the Beaver’s best offensive threat RB Yvenson Bernard might be ready to go from an injury,

“It’s going to be huge if Ev can’t play,'’ said Roy Schuening, the Beavers’ big right guard. “But Ev’s a fighter, and I’m definitely not counting him out.

“I would be kind of shocked if he didn’t play,'’ said Schuening. “He’s one of the toughest guys I’ve ever met. … personally, I think he’s going to be ready to play. He’d probably play with a broken leg if he could.'’

QB Matt Moore was also convinced that by Saturday, the crutches will be laying around campus somewhere and No. 26 will be attacking the Trojans, trying to end USC’s 27-game Pac-10 winning streak.

“He’s one of the toughest guys I’ve ever met in my life,'’ said Moore. “He told me yesterday, ‘I’ll be fine.’ And I truly believe that.'’

It would be huge. Even though the Beavers winning record isn’t built on their offense, Moore’s success passing is defintley predecated on establishing the run game first. Playing only a half Bernard netted better than a hundred yards against Arizona before getting injured. He was at a 144 against Washington a week before.

If Bernard (or his backup Polk) can get going early it gives the Beavers the best chance against the Trojans. It will open up the short-intermediate passing game which has plagued the Trojan’s secondary the past several weeks.

Sedrick Ellis shoudl continue to get back into the swing for the Trojans. But it is difficult to know if we’ll see any improvement in the secondary. Or any improvement in getting to the quarterback.

Certainly against Arizona State we saw more pressure coming from blitzes. A nice thing to finally see. The Trojans need to get to Moore, that would certainly help. More importantly however, but along the same lines of getting penetration is stopping the shifty Bernard in the backfield (if he sees significant time on the field come Saturday).

Bernard is a playmaker and if the Trojans have to keep eight men in the box and if the Beavers consistently get into second and medium situations, Moore and his junior recievers (including Sammie Stoughter who is far, far and away Moore’s favorite target) will be helped significantly.

USC Offense v. Oregon St. Defense

As Beaver blogger Building The Dam says,

Defense has been the strong point of our team this year. Most games, when the offense is having a bad day, the defense shows up to play. When the offense is having a good day, the defense still shows up to play. Our weakness is still pass coverage. We allowed Nate Longshore of Cal to throw for 341 yards and four touchdowns. As far as run defense goes, we’re having a good year, that is if you forget about the 240 yard, 5 touchdown performance Ian Johnson had against the Beavers in the Boise State game.

That is a big if (although Johnson has been having a monster year for Boise State). On any given day there are holes to find in the Oregon State defense. It is clear however looking at the stats that they’re more susceptible through the air.

That isn’t exactly the matchup the Trojans will probably end up wanting to exploit. Especially the way Chauncey Washington is coming around. He single handedly scored the game winning touchdown against Arizona State, running hard and often on that final drive.

As should be obvious from their run defense, the front seven is the strength of the Oregon State defense. Scout has this to say about the linebackers,

As good as the Beavers’ defensive line has been this season, the linebackers have played even better. Derrick Doggett and Alan Darlin are tied for the team lead in tackles, with 45 each. Doggett leads the team with nine tackles for loss, including three sacks. He’s also intercepted two passes, forced and recovered a fumble. Darlin ranks second on the team in both tackles for loss, with 8.5, and sacks, with four, to go along with two fumble recoveries.

These three linebackers will offer Chauncey Washington and the rest of the Trojan tailbacks an opportunity to prove themselves against some solid competition. While the front seven of the Beavers probably doesn’t stack up with Nebraska’s defensive front, playing at Reser Stadium may go toward evening that up.

QB Booty continues to stare down recievers, but interceptions aren’t the Beavers specialty. They will get pressure of the Trojan offensive line doesn’t come to play, especially that right side including Chilo and Kyle Williams.

As well, I no longer question Kiffin’s failure to call deep balls having seen Booty miss on some. That will come with time. With the way the running game is developing that can wait.

Hopefully the offensive line continues its development off that Arizona State game. The entire running game isn’t without some controversy. Clearly Moody has some “fumblitis” issues left. He wasn’t happy with the lack of trust from the coaches to him last week after he fumbled,

The elusive freshman had carried the ball on about half of USC’s running plays in the previous three weeks, but he had to watch most of the ASU game from the bench. He had just five carries after the fumble.

“They just really felt like the fumble kind of shook me up, and I wasn’t really focused after that, so they just reduced my carries,” Moody said. “Of course, it bothers me. It bothers any running back to get fewer carries.”

That one mistake could slow down what appeared to be a fast-rising college career. Moody rushed for 130 yards against Arizona three weeks earlier, but he watched from the sideline as Chauncey Washington pounded the ball a season-high 22 times against Arizona State.

“I wasn’t really shaken up. They just thought I was shaken up by the look I had in my face,” Moody said.

“I’m just going to keep on doing what I do, just play my game and really not worry about it. That’s in the past. I’m going to look toward the future.”

It’s been a rough stretch for Moody. He had a bandage over his left eye from where defensive end Brian Cushing inadvertently slugged him during practice.

Carroll said USC was simply riding the hot hand when it kept feeding Washington the ball.

“It was all about Chauncey. That was the right thing to do at the time the way he was going,” Carroll said. “You like going with the big guy; you like the experience and all that.”

Washington is getting healthy and will continue to get the brunt of the carriers. But even after Arizona State I think Moody will continue to play the speed back role. We’ll see.

Other Stuff

This could be a slugfest with both teams trying to establish the run.

I have no doubt Mike Riley will let Moore take some shots down field with the shaky play of the young Trojans secondary at time. Especially if QB Moore is getting protection early. But don’t expect a whole lot of bullets early (or often). He’ll take his shots at oppurtune times.

I’m of the opinion that Washington will have a monster game. If Bernard can’t play then this game could get out of hand and the Trojans could finally have a “break out.”

The Beaver offensive line is a fine unit, but if Holt continues his trend of pressure Moore can be gotten to. This especially if the Beavers are without the shifty running of Bernard and are able to hold up the more “downhill” Polk and force Moore to throw more than he would like.

With pressure the Trojan secondary will do its job. As such, it would be good for the Trojans to see Moore throw the ball 35+ times.

I don’t know we will see an Ian Johnson remix, but expect Chauncey to be effect and Moody to be very complimentary (and hopefully hold onto the ball).

If you thought we relied on the run game in previous games, this one, especially in the beginning will be even more like that.

We lead the entire game and open it up more in the second half. It’s enough of a trouncing that Sanchez gets his turn in the fourth quarter even.

Trojans 38 - Beaver 10

[Coach Carroll Press Conference]
[Tucson Citizen: Young Trojans To Get Better]
[Joe Jares: Second Half Team]
[CFN Week 9 Predictions]

A Bounce Back Week


Uncategorized

Week 9 picks are up. After having a week, last week in which a monkey with darts should’ve statistically done as well (my worst week of the year), I feel a little more comfortable with my picks this week.

The one’s I’m “really” confident on? Well, not to anger the Orgeron, but…

Auburn (-19.0) v. Ole Miss

As well, I’d go with…
USC (-10.5) v. Oregon State - Especially if you find it at 10 points
Texas A&M (-4.5) v. Baylor
Tennessee (-3.5) v. South Carolina - Way, way too much credit to the Old Ball Coach’s success versus the Volunteers at Florida

If I had to pick one of my not to cover picks (Northwestern, Bufallo ?!?!, Miami, Georgia), I’d have to go with

Miami (+5.0) v. Georgia Tech

I only give that one because despite always being nervous about picking a team not to cover I’m 80% on the year when I pick the underdog.

Let’s see if I can do better than last week and go 5/5 on my “confident” picks.

The Mystical World Of Consumer Driven Health Plans


Healthcare PolicyHealth NewsHealthcare CostsInsurance

So the trouble with high deductible plans saving us significant money is that, stunningly to some people, healthcare costs are actually being driven by a very select group of consumers.

For an overview on consumer directed health plans go to KaiserEDU’s tutorial (that website is amazing for any students interested in health care policy).

For instance the top 1% of the sickest Americans, the largest health care consumers, account for about 25% of the spending. Whenever I see that I’m stunned by it. 80% of health care spending is accounted for by 20% of patients.

The chronically ill are the consumers.

Two points to make.

The maximal effects of CDHPs going to take a generation to show their true and full savings power (obviously the current generation of very sick aren’t going to be purchasing this plans - not that anyone is, really - we’ll have to wait for a new generation to purchase these plans…then slowly get chronic disease processes and move into the top 20% of health care consumers). That might be time the American health care system doesn’t have.

And, CDHP benefits may be offset by single individual high costs. What I mean is - ask yourself in what way could spending on health care be distributed where high deductible consumer driven plans would be most beneficial in influencing patient decisions and reducing the cost and spending of the entire system?

Well, if America’s health spending was accounted for by an even distribution where every patient was spending just up to, or slightly above their CDHI deductible, these plans would probably have maximum effect.

But that’s not the way it is working. We have a “few” individuals consuming well, well above what their deductible would be. As well, these chronically/seriously ill are the one’s least likely to be able to reduce their consumption…I imagine that is what we’ll find at least in the long run study of the chronically ill and high deductible plans.


La La La La La…I Can’t Hear You

It isn’t all bad news though. I actually support CDHI, it certainly can lower costs I believe. We may just be heaping too much promise on it. It certainly won’t be for everyone.

The Health Affairs Blog has a post up on a round table discussing how consumber driven health plans might be made more enticing to the chronically ill and how they can help protect them.

This is my favorite suggestion. One I would hope everyone would fight strongly to see happen.

Defining “preventive care” broadly. Plans should consider broadly defining “preventive care” — which can be covered before the deductible is satisfied — to include not just services such as mammography and immunizations, but also maintenance drug therapy for chronic diseases. Such therapy can prevent adverse events such as hospitalizations for uncontrolled diabetes, but maintenance drugs are most often excluded from preventive care. Again, participants suggested changes in Treasury regulations that may bar considering maintenance therapy as preventive care in HSA-eligible plans.

And of course any of these suggestions can be met. It is merely a question of the premium rise. One of the promises of CDHI was that it might be more afforable to those who currently aren’t protected by insurance.

Early Voting

Thursday, October 26th 2006
PoliticsMiscellaneousCivil Liberties

This Is Stickied At The Top
Go Below For The Most Recent Posts

Early voting is up in my home county. It is busy. Even in some bad weather turn out has been high. South Texas is significantly more liberal than other parts of the state. No surprise should exist there. That might help explain the turnout (although I suspect we’ll see good turnout for a midterm all over the country - and I don’t see how that could help the Republicans).

You can check Bexar county early voting stations on this map, check early voting numbers, and if you wait until November 7th you can find your polling place with this little applet.

Any of my classmates who look at this while searching for school materials should remember to vote. And if you’re not registered here and didn’t request an absentee ballot well shame on you since the date for that has passed. And if you’re not registered at all…well really shame on you.

I had a very “independent” ballot. Like I’ve mentioned a bunch of times, I’m pretty libertarian and despite being fearful for the future of Bush’s tax cuts and for the future of medicine I just couldn’t shake the civil liberty issues which have plaqued this administration like this and this and the deficit and debt.

Voting and politics are often times private things but with such a contentious election I thought I’d actually share who I endorsed.

For the reasons above, and not necessarily for the strength of the candidate himself I voted for Democrat John Courage. I think it would be a good thing for this country to have a split government. At the least I’d like to give control of one of the Chambers to the Dems (which if it doesn’t happen I think should make us all suspicious :) ).


Can He Force A Run Off?

It was quite possible I would’ve cast a libertarian vote, but while still a long shot, the Smith-Courage “special election” is much closer than anyone could’ve imagine. I didn’t feel I could “throw” my vote. I was thrust into this district, as it was one of just five that the panel of judges redrew after the Supreme Court invalidated the 23rd district (which obviously affected the borders of more than just the 23rd…it meant redrawing the borders of its neighbors as well),

Since the district was redrawn past the normal filing date for candidates to run it is holding a “special election.” A free for all with a half dozen candidates. The idea however for Courage (the most promising contender to incumbent Lamar Smith) is to hold Smith under 50% of the vote and force a run off.

There is some evidence that might happen. Even though Smith has outearned Courage by about 4 to 1, Courage’s fundraising has been impressive. It needs to be realized he didn’t enter the race until district was drawn. As such he was at a significant disadvantage in terms of both funds and infrastructure in place. Not to mention Smith has been continually campaigning for his 20 years in Congress.

But Courage had reason to be hopeful when he entered - looking at Smith’s numbers. I can’t blame those numbers, even as a tangental Republican supporter (my interests overlap more with them than the Donkeys typically), Smith has been a poor performer by some standards including his hard line support for DeLay. He seems more attuned to national issues than the concerns of District 21. I think anyone, even his supporters would have a hard time arguing effectively against that complaint.

Still, he is a leader in the Republican party and a strong voice nationally (which drew him the support of both the Express News & Statesman). If elected and the Republicans remain in control he’ll likely be the chair of the Judiciary committee (not a small position by any stretch). On the flip side Courage is far more liberal than I’d like. A more moderate Democrat would’ve made the decision easier.

But I’ve explained my vote as one of national concern rather than a complete condemnation of Smith or very strong attraction to John Courage. The race will probably go to Lamar Smith without a run off, but its clear I’m hoping the Democrats take the House.



Being Outdoors Makes Him Look “Strong”…Or So His Imagine Consultant Told Him

My other two “major” votes went to Republican Rick Perry for governor and Republican Senator Hutchinson. Neither of them is really in a position to lose, although Perry is looking to get elected with perhaps less than 35% of the vote (!). It is stunning Texas doesn’t a have provision for the winner to recieve at least 50% of the vote.


Reward For Pushing So Hard For Proposition 12

Perry isn’t exactly the state’s most effective governor ever. I might’ve been tempted to vote for Strayhorn, even though I question her past, or even Kinky. But I couldn’t forget about Perry’s strong support for physicians. Granted the man appears (to an extreme) more concerned with politics than policy or what is actually good for the state but while he has neglected major areas, he has done some good. I think, I hope, that after such a “tough” (well, comparatively) race he’ll sit down and govern better the second time around.



The “Gentleman” Politician - Despite The Fact He’s Going To Win By 15 Points Perry Has Thrown Out A Lot Of Attack Ads

And as always, the very bright and proper Senator Hutchinson is the obvious choice for the state. She’s served well in Washington. Not to mention she’s going to absolutely cruch Radnofsky.

Go out and vote on November 7th everyone.

Poor Quality Celebrity Voices Disagree With Michael J. Fox

Tuesday, October 24th 2006
Healthcare PolicyHealth NewsPoliticsStem CellsVideo

What the hell is this? A poor quality commercial to air in Missouri for Jim Talent and enlisting the likes of Kurt Warner and Patricia Heaton which denounces stem cell research.



Just Strange, Strange, Strange

If you remember, a Michael J. Fox commercial encouraging Missouri voters to cast a ballot against incumbent Jim Talent for his opposition to stem cell research aired in St. Louis (actually maybe tonight during the World Series).

H/T Wired News

Volume 3 #5


Health NewsGrand Rounds

Grand Rounds is up at Health Care Law Blog. The first foray the legal profession has had into hosting this weekly carnival.

Next week it is at Dr. Hebert’s Medical Gumbo. Submissions can be made here.

Pharma In For A Surprise?

Monday, October 23rd 2006
Healthcare PolicyHealth NewsPharmacuticalsHealthcare CostsMedicare/Medicaid

In case you don’t know the government is specifically prohibited from negotiating down the price of pharmacuticals in Plan D (the Medicare drug plan). How in the world can that be? Well the pharma industry has a good lobby.

The Health Care Blog has a post up discussing the possibility that that stipulation in the Plan D law will be overturned come the next Congress.

Although the post isn’t very confident of the speed with which that might happen, the entire idea sounds good to me. I may have questions behind the philosophy of Plan D (and Medicare in general) but my God if it is going to exist why in the world wouldn’t you take full advantage of the government’s clout?

About The Blog


Medicine, healthcare policy, and random commentary from a medical student still on the naive side of the fence.
I'm a third year medical student in Texas.

I did my undergrad work in USC's School of Cinema-Television Cinematic Arts. I have a Bachelors of Fine Arts in Writing for Screen & Television. I loved it, but a future of waiting tables and taking meetings with B-List producers was not for me.

This blog is ostensibly to discuss healthcare policy and maybe educate a few of my fellow medical students. But it will stray into current events, politics, and other science topics when they draw my interest



Other odd notes about me:

Disclaimer


Nothing on this website is to be taken as medical advice. Please seek counsel from a physician for any questions regarding your health.
Nothing on this website is to be taken as medical advice. I am not a physician. Please consult a physician concerning any health related questions.

This blog is entirely self funded. It accepts no advertising or other supporting revenue. The author has no relevant financial relationships to disclose.

Unless otherwise noted the media on this blog is under the copyright of the blog author, used under a Creative Common or free use license with appropriate accreditation or is in the public domain. If you believe images or video posted on this blog are copyrighted works used inappropriately please contact me.

Endorsements


"Please be more precise in your practice of medicine than you are in your blogging!"
- Mark Lanier

"Nice work."
- Commenter

"I really enjoy your blog. Thanks for taking the time to put it together."
- Rob Ebrahimi

"The guy who wrote this [blog] is an idiot."
- Commenter

Contact


Topics of Coverage

Posts & Links of Note

Recent Comments


sygul (on Why Physicians Should Be Able To Seek Confidential Alcohol & Drug Treatment): "This is a comprehensive addiction portal focusing..."
scoobz RVA (on Hygiene For The Obese): "I think that this is handy but i still think that everyone should use their own hand"
Pam Walter (on Taking Claims Of Malpractice To The Internet): "I just have to correct this: As Mr. Walter presents it, it doesn’t appear that..."
Θεμις Μαντζαβινος (on Doctor Blogs Raise Concerns?): "Hi It is a very nice and great post and i really appriciate it."

Education Links


Guidelines & Research Admissions Residency Match Pathology Pharmacology Microbiology Physical Exam Anatomy & Embryology Neuroscience Histology Biochemistry & Cell Biology Physiology Medicine Pediatrics Surgery Obstetrics & Gynecology Radiology Psychiatry

Policy Links


Medical News Groups & Resources Tort Reform Covering The Uninsured Reports & Essays

Currently Writing

Currently Reading

Currently Watching

Currently Rotating

Medicine
Neurology
Family Medicine
Geriatrics
Pediatrics
Winter Break
General Surgery
Neurosurgery
Cardiothoracic Surgery
Ob/Gyn

Psychiatry

Currently Doing

Currently Viewing

[Complete Photos]

Blogroll


Medical Students Health Professionals Patients Health Policy Wonks Politics Space & Technology

Archives

Social Internet



Meta